Monster who doesn't want any eyes, thank you, peeled or otherwise
Monster who sees the trap. Knows it's a trap. But they'll still walk into it. What else can they do?
Monster who didn't even come near this... what was it that you said was stolen? "Christmas"? Never even heard of it.
Monster who was swept out to sea twenty years ago, but doesn't hold a grudge
Monster who's offended you think them a coldblooded killer. Do they look like a reptile to you?
Monster who has the most intriguing eyes, you could really get lost in them...
Monster who isn't a traditionalist and knows seventh daughters of seventh daughters are just as much to be feared, if not more
Monster who is looking for their lost pe— Ah, there she is! Now, don't make any sudden movements...